Features, discussions, tips, tricks, questions, problems and feedback

Analog Signals Vdc vs mAdc The differences and installation details

#1

Analog Signals Vdc vs mAdc The differences and installation details

Introduction
A comprehensive breakdown of mAdc (milliampere DC) and Vdc (volt DC) analog signals, focusing on their differences, advantages, and specific details about 4-20mA, 0-20mA, 0-10Vdc, and 1-5Vdc standards used in industrial automation and control systems.

1. Overview of mAdc and Vdc Analog Signals

mAdc (Milliampere DC):

  • Definition: A current-based analog signal where the signal is represented by a DC current, typically in the range of milliamperes (mA).
  • Common Standards: 4-20mA (most prevalent), 0-20mA (less common).
  • Applications: Used in process control, instrumentation, and industrial automation for transmitting sensor data (e.g., pressure, temperature, flow) to controllers or displays.
  • Operation: The current flows through a loop (often called a current loop), and the magnitude of the current represents the measured variable.

Vdc (Volt DC):

  • Definition: A voltage-based analog signal where the signal is represented by a DC voltage.
  • Common Standards: 0-10Vdc, 1-5Vdc.
  • Applications: Used in control systems, HVAC, and automation for transmitting analog signals, often for setpoints or control outputs.
  • Operation: The voltage difference across a circuit represents the measured or controlled variable.

2. Advantages of mAdc vs. Vdc

mAdc Advantages:

  1. Long-Distance Transmission: Current signals are less affected by wire resistance, making them ideal for long runs (up to 1-2 km with proper setup).
  2. Noise Immunity: Less susceptible to electromagnetic interference (EMI) and voltage drops.
  3. Fault Detection: A 4-20mA loop dropping to 0mA clearly indicates a fault (e.g., broken wire).
  4. Loop-Powered Devices: Many 4-20mA devices are powered by the loop itself, eliminating the need for a separate power supply.
  5. Linear Scaling: The 4-20mA range provides a linear representation of the measured variable, simplifying calibration.

Vdc Advantages:

  1. Simpler Implementation: Voltage signals require simpler circuitry, reducing cost for basic applications.
  2. Wider Compatibility: Common in consumer electronics, HVAC, and non-industrial applications.
  3. Higher Bandwidth: Voltage signals can support faster-changing signals (though rare in industrial applications).
  4. Easier to Measure: Voltage can be measured directly with simple multimeters or ADCs without needing a shunt resistor.
  5. Lower Power Consumption: Voltage-based systems may consume less power in some configurations.

3. Detailed Breakdown of Specific Standards

4-20mA

  • Description:

    • Industry-standard current loop signal.
    • Represents 0-100% of the measured variable (e.g., 4mA = 0%, 20mA = 100%).
    • Often used in process control for sensors (pressure, temperature, flow) and actuators (valves, pumps).

  • Advantages:

    • Live Zero: 4mA as the minimum allows detection of faults (0mA = broken loop).
    • Loop-Powered: Devices can be powered by the 12-36Vdc loop voltage.
    • Robust: Reliable over long distances and in noisy environments.
    • Standardized: Widely supported by PLCs, DCS, and instrumentation.

  • Disadvantages:

    • Requires precise current regulation, increasing device complexity.
    • Limited to low-bandwidth signals (slow changes).
    • Not ideal for high-speed applications.

  • Applications:

    • Oil and gas, chemical plants, water treatment, and manufacturing.
    • Example: A pressure transmitter outputs 4mA at 0 psi and 20mA at 100 psi.

0-20mA

  • Description:
    • Less common than 4-20mA.
    • Represents the full range of the variable from 0mA to 20mA.
    • Used in some legacy systems or specific applications.
  • Advantages:
    • Simpler scaling (0mA = 0% of range).
    • Compatible with some older equipment.
  • Disadvantages:
    • No “live zero,” so faults (0mA) are indistinguishable from a valid 0% signal.
    • Less common, reducing interoperability.
    • Not loop-powered in most cases, requiring external power.
  • Applications:
    • Rare, found in older industrial systems or niche applications.
    • Example: Legacy flow meters or controllers.

0-10Vdc

  • Description:

    • Voltage-based signal ranging from 0V to 10V.
    • Common in HVAC, lighting control, and building automation.
    • Represents 0-100% of the control or measurement range.

  • Advantages:

    • Simple to implement and measure.
    • Compatible with many controllers and actuators.
    • Low-cost for short-distance applications.

  • Disadvantages:

    • Susceptible to voltage drops over long distances (>100m).
    • Noise can degrade signal quality.
    • 0V could indicate a fault or a valid signal, complicating diagnostics.

  • Applications:

    • HVAC dampers, variable frequency drives (VFDs), and lighting systems.
    • Example: A 0-10Vdc signal controls a damper from fully closed (0V) to fully open (10V).

1-5Vdc

  • Description:

    • Voltage-based signal ranging from 1V to 5V.
    • Less common but used in some control systems and sensors.
    • Similar to 4-20mA’s “live zero” concept.

  • Advantages:

    • Live zero (1V) allows fault detection (0V = fault).
    • Simple and low-cost for short distances.
    • Compatible with some PLCs and microcontrollers.

  • Disadvantages:

    • Limited distance due to voltage drop and noise.
    • Less common than 0-10Vdc, reducing availability.
    • Requires careful calibration to avoid signal degradation.

  • Applications:

    • Small-scale automation, sensor outputs, and some embedded systems.
    • Example: A temperature sensor outputs 1V at 0°C and 5V at 100°C.

4. Practical Considerations

  • Wiring and Installation:

    • mAdc: Typically uses twisted-pair cables to reduce noise. Requires proper grounding to avoid ground loops.
    • Vdc: May require shielded cables for long runs. Grounding is critical to prevent noise.

  • Power Requirements:

    • 4-20mA: Loop voltage (12-36Vdc) powers the device.
    • 0-20mA: Often requires external power.
    • 0-10Vdc/1-5Vdc: May need a separate power supply for active devices.

  • Calibration:

    • Both require calibration to ensure accurate scaling (e.g., 4mA = 0%, 20mA = 100%).
    • Vdc signals may need adjustment for load impedance effects.

  • Interoperability:

    • 4-20mA is the de facto standard in process industries.
    • 0-10Vdc is common in building automation.
    • Check device specifications for compatibility.

5. Recommendations

  • Choose 4-20mA for:

    • Long-distance, noisy environments.
    • Process industries requiring robust fault detection.
    • Loop-powered devices.

  • Choose 0-20mA for:

    • Legacy systems (rare).
    • Applications where fault detection isn’t critical.

  • Choose 0-10Vdc for:

    • Short-distance, cost-sensitive applications.
    • HVAC or building automation.

  • Choose 1-5Vdc for:

    • Systems needing a live zero with voltage signals.
    • Small-scale or embedded applications.

image
image.png984×372 107 KB

Step-by-Step Procedure for Wiring Analog Signals (0–10 VDC, 0–20 mA) for PLCs, VSDs, and Field Equipment

Prerequisites

  • Hardware :
    • Signal Source : Analog output device (e.g., potentiometer for 0–10 VDC, 4–20 mA transmitter, or PLC analog output module).
    • Receiving Device : PLC, VSD, or field recorder with analog input capabilities.
    • Cables : Shielded twisted-pair cable (18–22 AWG, with foil or braided shield).
    • Connectors : Terminal blocks, crimps, or spring terminals compatible with device specifications.
    • Grounding : Ground bus bar or grounding point in the control panel.
    • Testing Tools : Multimeter (voltage/current modes), oscilloscope (optional for noise analysis).
  • Tools :
    • Wire strippers, crimping tool, and screwdriver for terminal connections.
    • Cable cutters and shielding preparation tools (e.g., for foil or braid stripping).
    • Ferrite beads or EMI filters (optional, for high-noise environments).
  • Documentation :
    • Device manuals (e.g., PLC analog I/O module datasheet, VSD wiring guide, transmitter installation manual).
    • Control system wiring diagram, including terminal assignments for inputs/outputs.
  • Safety :
    • Power off all devices before wiring to prevent electrical shock or equipment damage.
    • Verify proper grounding to avoid EMI issues or safety hazards.
    • Wear personal protective equipment (PPE) during installation.

Step-by-Step Procedure for Wiring Analog Signals

Step 1: Select the Appropriate Cable

  1. Choose Shielded Twisted-Pair Cable :
  • Select shielded twisted-pair cable to minimize EMI/EMF interference. The twisted pair cancels differential noise, while the shield blocks external electromagnetic fields.
  • For 0–10 VDC : Use a cable with at least one twisted pair (18–20 AWG) for voltage signals.
  • For 0–20 mA or 4–20 mA : Use a similar cable (20–22 AWG) for current loops, which are less sensitive to cable resistance but require shielding.
  • Ensure the cable’s voltage rating exceeds the system’s maximum (e.g., 300 V for typical control circuits).
  1. Verify Cable Specifications :
  • Confirm conductor size (e.g., 0.5–1.5 mm² or 18–22 AWG) to minimize resistance over the required distance.
  • Check shield type: Foil (100% coverage, ideal for high-frequency noise) or braided (better for low-frequency noise and durability). Foil with a drain wire is common for analog signals.

Step 2: Plan the Wiring Route

  1. Determine Cable Length and Route :
  • Measure the distance between the signal source (e.g., transmitter, PLC output) and the receiving device (e.g., PLC input, VSD).
  • Distance Limits :
    • 0–10 VDC : Reliable up to 50–100 meters, limited by voltage drops (IR loss) and noise susceptibility.
    • 0–20 mA/4–20 mA : Reliable up to 1000–2000 meters, as current loops are less affected by resistance (loop resistance typically < 500–1000 Ω, depending on power supply).
  • Route cables away from high-power lines (e.g., motor cables, VSD outputs, or transformers) to avoid EMI. Maintain at least 30 cm separation from power cables or use metal conduit for additional shielding.
  1. Avoid Ground Loops :
  • Plan to ground the cable shield at one end only (typically the control panel or receiving device end) to prevent ground loops, which can induce noise currents.

Step 3: Wire the Analog Signal

  1. Power Off Devices :
  • Disconnect power to the signal source, receiving device, and related equipment.
  • Wait for capacitors to discharge (e.g., 5–10 minutes for VSDs or power supplies).
  1. Connect 0–10 VDC Signal :
  • Example Setup : Wiring a potentiometer to a VSD analog input.
    • Positive (+) : Connect one outer terminal of a 10 kΩ potentiometer to the VSD’s voltage supply terminal (e.g., +10 V output, often labeled “+V” or “10V”).
    • Wiper (center) : Connect to the VSD’s analog voltage input (e.g., “AI1” or “V_IN”).
    • Negative (−) : Connect the other outer terminal to the VSD’s common/ground (e.g., “COM” or “0V”).
  • Example Setup : Wiring a PLC analog output to a VSD.
    • Connect the PLC’s analog output (+) (e.g., “V_OUT”) to the VSD’s voltage input (e.g., “AI1”).
    • Connect the PLC’s analog output (−) (e.g., “COM”) to the VSD’s common (e.g., “COM”).
  • Use one twisted pair: one wire for the signal (e.g., wiper to AI1), the other for the common (e.g., COM). The +10 V supply can use a separate wire or the same cable’s second pair.
  1. Connect 0–20 mA or 4–20 mA Signal :
  • Example Setup : Wiring a 4–20 mA transmitter (e.g., pressure or temperature transmitter) to a PLC analog input.
    • Positive (+) : Connect the transmitter’s output (+) to the PLC’s current input (e.g., “I+” or “AI_I”).
    • Negative (−) : Connect the transmitter’s output (−) to the PLC’s common (e.g., “COM” or “M”).
    • If the transmitter requires loop power, connect a 24 VDC power supply in series:
      • Power supply (+) to transmitter’s (+) terminal.
      • Transmitter’s (−) to PLC’s current input.
      • PLC’s common to power supply (−).
  • Example Setup : Wiring a PLC analog output to a VSD.
    • Connect the PLC’s current output (+) (e.g., “I_OUT”) to the VSD’s current input (e.g., “AI2” or “I_IN”).
    • Connect the PLC’s current output (−) to the VSD’s common (e.g., “COM”).
  • Use one twisted pair: one wire for the current signal (e.g., I_IN), the other for the common (e.g., COM).
  1. Secure Connections :
  • Strip wires to the correct length (e.g., 7–10 mm, per device manual).
  • Use ferrules or crimp terminals for reliable connections in screw or spring terminals.
  • Tighten terminals to the manufacturer’s torque specification (e.g., 0.5–0.8 Nm for typical PLC/VSD terminals).

Step 4: Implement Shielding

  1. Prepare the Shield :
  • Strip the outer insulation to expose the shield (foil or braid) at the grounding end (typically the control panel or receiving device).
  • For foil shields, ensure the drain wire is accessible for grounding.
  • For braided shields, twist the braid into a single conductor or use a shield clamp.
  1. Ground the Shield :
  • Connect the shield (drain wire or braided conductor) to the ground terminal at one end only (e.g., PLC’s ground terminal, VSD’s protective earth terminal, or control panel’s grounding bar).
  • Grounding at the receiving device end (e.g., PLC or VSD) is preferred to centralize noise dissipation.
  • Do not ground the shield at both ends, as this creates a ground loop, allowing EMI to induce currents.
  1. Protect the Unshielded End :
  • At the ungrounded end (e.g., transmitter or sensor), insulate the shield with electrical tape or heat-shrink tubing to prevent accidental contact with other conductors or ground points.

Step 5: Minimize EMI/EMF Noise

  1. Route Cables Strategically :
  • Run analog signal cables in separate conduits or cable trays from power cables (e.g., motor cables, VSD outputs, or high-voltage lines).
  • If crossing power cables is unavoidable, cross at a 90-degree angle to minimize electromagnetic coupling.
  • Avoid running analog cables parallel to high-frequency sources (e.g., VSDs, inverters, or RF equipment).
  1. Add EMI Filters (Optional) :
  • Install ferrite beads or chokes on the analog cable near the receiving device to suppress high-frequency noise.
  • Use an EMI filter on the VSD’s power input or PLC’s power supply if significant noise is present.
  1. Configure Device Settings :
  • Enable built-in noise filters on the receiving device (e.g., PLC analog input filtering via software, VSD input filter settings like analog input time constant).
  • For PLCs, configure analog input averaging in software to smooth out noise-induced fluctuations.
  • For transmitters, ensure proper configuration (e.g., damping settings) to stabilize output signals.

Step 6: Test the Analog Signal

  1. Power On and Verify :
  • Restore power to the signal source, receiving device, and any related equipment.
  • Check for error codes (e.g., analog input faults on PLCs, overcurrent on VSDs, or transmitter diagnostics).
  1. Test 0–10 VDC Signal :
  • Use a multimeter in voltage mode to measure between the signal wire (e.g., PLC’s AI1) and common (e.g., COM).
  • Adjust the signal source (e.g., potentiometer or PLC output) from minimum to maximum and verify the voltage ranges from 0 to 10 VDC.
  • Confirm the receiving device responds correctly (e.g., VSD speed changes from 0 to maximum frequency, PLC registers 0–100% of range).
  1. Test 0–20 mA or 4–20 mA Signal :
  • Use a multimeter in current mode (in series with the loop) to measure the current between the signal wire (e.g., PLC’s I+) and common (e.g., COM).
  • Adjust the signal source (e.g., transmitter or PLC output) and verify the current ranges from 0–20 mA or 4–20 mA.
  • Confirm the receiving device responds (e.g., PLC scales 4–20 mA to process variable, VSD adjusts speed proportionally).
  1. Check for Noise :
  • Monitor the signal for fluctuations using the receiving device’s diagnostics (e.g., PLC’s watch table, VSD’s display, or transmitter’s diagnostic interface).
  • If noise is detected (e.g., erratic PLC readings or unstable VSD speed), recheck shielding, grounding, and cable routing.

Step 7: Finalize and Document

  1. Secure Cables :
  • Use cable ties or clips to secure the analog cable along its route, preventing strain or movement.
  • Label cables at both ends (e.g., “PLC AI1 4–20 mA”, “VSD AI2 0–10 V”) for future maintenance.
  1. Document the Setup :
  • Update the wiring diagram with terminal assignments, cable type, and grounding details.
  • Record device configurations (e.g., PLC analog input scaling, VSD analog input parameters, transmitter range settings).
  • Save configurations using device-specific software or manual records.

Why 4–20 mA or 1–5 VDC is Sometimes Preferred

Advantages of 4–20 mA

  1. Long-Distance Reliability :
  • Current loops maintain signal integrity over long distances (1000–2000 meters) because the current remains constant regardless of cable resistance (within loop limits, e.g., < 500–1000 Ω for 24 VDC loops).
  • Voltage signals like 0–10 VDC suffer from voltage drops (V = IR), limiting their range to 50–100 meters due to cable resistance and load impedance.
  1. Noise Immunity :
  • Current signals are less susceptible to EMI/EMF because noise-induced voltage spikes have minimal effect on current flow in a low-impedance loop (typically 250–500 Ω).
  • Voltage signals (0–10 VDC) are high-impedance and more prone to noise, especially in environments with VSDs, motors, or RF equipment.
  1. Live Zero Fault Detection :
  • The 4 mA “live zero” allows detection of faults (e.g., broken wires, failed transmitters), as 0 mA indicates a fault condition.
  • With 0–20 mA or 0–10 VDC, 0 mA or 0 V could represent a valid signal (minimum value) or a fault, requiring additional diagnostics.
  1. Industry Standard :
  • 4–20 mA is the global standard for process control, supported by most PLCs, VSDs, and field transmitters, ensuring interoperability across devices.
  1. Linear Scaling :
  • The 4–20 mA range maps linearly to process variables (e.g., 4 mA = 0%, 20 mA = 100%), simplifying calibration and scaling compared to 0–20 mA, which may require offset adjustments.

Advantages of 1–5 VDC

  1. Compatibility with Voltage-Based Systems :
  • Some devices or legacy systems use 1–5 VDC inputs, making it a preferred choice for specific applications or retrofits.
  • Can be derived from 4–20 mA using a 250 Ω precision resistor (4 mA × 250 Ω = 1 V, 20 mA × 250 Ω = 5 V), allowing voltage-based systems to leverage current loop signals.
  1. Live Zero Detection :
  • The 1 V “live zero” enables fault detection (e.g., 0 V indicates a broken wire or fault), unlike 0–10 VDC where 0 V is ambiguous.
  • Provides similar diagnostic benefits to 4–20 mA when used with a resistor.
  1. Lower Power Consumption :
  • 1–5 VDC signals require less power than 0–10 VDC due to the smaller voltage range, which is advantageous in low-power or battery-operated systems.
  1. Noise Tolerance via Conversion :
  • When derived from a 4–20 mA signal, 1–5 VDC inherits the current loop’s noise immunity, making it more robust than 0–10 VDC in noisy environments.

When 0–10 VDC or 0–20 mA is Used

  • 0–10 VDC :
    • Preferred for short-distance, low-cost applications (e.g., potentiometer to VSD or PLC) where noise is minimal and distances are < 50 m.
    • Common in HVAC, lighting control, or small-scale automation (e.g., controlling VSD speed with a local potentiometer).
    • Simpler to implement as it doesn’t require loop power or precise resistors.
  • 0–20 mA :
    • Less common than 4–20 mA but used in some legacy systems or specific sensors/transmitters that output a full 0–20 mA range.
    • Lacks the live zero feature, making fault detection more complex, so it’s typically avoided in modern systems.

Why 4–20 mA is Often the Default

  • 4–20 mA is the industry standard for process control due to its long-distance reliability, noise immunity, fault detection, and universal compatibility with PLCs, VSDs, and field equipment.
  • 1–5 VDC is a niche alternative when voltage signals are required, often as a derivative of 4–20 mA, offering similar benefits in specific applications.

Shielding, EMI/EMF, and Distance Considerations

Shielding

  • Purpose : Shields (foil or braid) protect analog signals from EMI/EMF by redirecting external electromagnetic fields to ground, preventing induced voltages or currents in the signal wires.
  • Best Practices :
    • Use 100% coverage foil shields for high-frequency EMI (e.g., from VSDs or RF equipment).
    • Use braided shields for low-frequency EMI (e.g., 50/60 Hz from power lines) or where mechanical durability is needed.
    • Ground the shield at one end only (preferably the control panel) to avoid ground loops.
    • Ensure the shield is continuous along the cable length, with no gaps or breaks.
  • Impact on Performance : Proper shielding can reduce noise-induced errors by 90% or more, ensuring stable readings (e.g., consistent VSD speed or accurate PLC measurements).

EMI/EMF (Electromagnetic Interference/Electromagnetic Fields)

  • Sources :
    • High-Power Equipment : VSD outputs, motor cables, or transformers generate strong electromagnetic fields.
    • Switching Devices : Relays, contactors, or PWM signals from VSDs produce high-frequency noise.
    • External Sources : Nearby radio frequency (RF) equipment, welding machines, or lightning strikes.
  • Effects on Analog Signals :
    • 0–10 VDC : High-impedance voltage signals are highly susceptible to EMI, causing voltage fluctuations (e.g., a 1 V spike can shift a 10 V signal by 10%).
    • 0–20 mA/4–20 mA : Low-impedance current loops are less affected, as noise-induced voltages have minimal impact on current flow.
  • Mitigation :
    • Use shielded twisted-pair cables to cancel differential noise and block external fields.
    • Route cables away from EMI sources (e.g., >30 cm from motor cables).
    • Apply ferrite beads or EMI filters to suppress high-frequency noise.
    • Enable device noise filters (e.g., PLC input averaging, VSD analog input filtering).
    • Ground the control panel and devices properly to a single-point earth ground.

Distance Considerations

  • 0–10 VDC :

    • Maximum Distance : 50–100 meters, limited by:
      • Voltage Drop : Cable resistance ® causes a drop (V = IR). For a 20 AWG cable (0.052 Ω/m), a 100 m run (200 m round-trip) at 10 mA load gives a 0.104 V drop, or 1% of a 10 V signal.
      • Noise Susceptibility : Longer cables act as antennas, picking up more EMI.
    • Mitigation : Use thicker cables (e.g., 18 AWG, 0.033 Ω/m) or signal conditioners (e.g., voltage boosters) for longer runs.

  • 0–20 mA/4–20 mA :

    • Maximum Distance : 1000–2000 meters, limited by:
      • Loop Resistance : Total resistance (cable + receiver) must be within the transmitter’s drive capability (e.g., < 500 Ω for a 24 VDC loop). For 20 AWG (0.052 Ω/m), a 1000 m run (2000 m round-trip) gives 104 Ω, well within limits.
      • Power Supply : Ensure the loop power supply (e.g., 24 VDC) can drive the total loop resistance.
    • Advantages : Minimal voltage drop issues and lower EMI susceptibility make 4–20 mA ideal for long distances.

  • Shielding Impact : Shielding is critical for long runs, as EMI pickup increases with cable length. A properly shielded 4–20 mA signal can maintain accuracy over 1000 m, while an unshielded 0–10 VDC signal may become unreliable beyond 20–30 m in noisy environments.

Notes

  • Testing for Noise :

    • Use an oscilloscope to monitor analog signals for spikes or fluctuations.
    • Compare readings with expected values (e.g., PLC watch table vs. transmitter output).
    • Simulate faults (e.g., disconnect wire) to verify 4–20 mA live zero detection (0 mA = fault).

  • Environment-Specific Considerations :

    • In high-EMI settings (e.g., near VSDs or arc welders), use metal conduit or armored cable for extra shielding.
    • In outdoor installations, use UV-resistant, weatherproof cables and protect against lightning-induced surges with surge suppressors.

  • Standards :

    • 4–20 mA is the standard for process control, ensuring compatibility across devices.
    • Follow international wiring standards (e.g., those for fieldbus and analog signals) for safety and performance.

  • Summary :

    image
    image.jpg1003×1249 248 KB